Did Sebastian kill Edgar in “The Afterparty?”

In the head-spinning labyrinth of Apple TV's "The Afterparty", the question lurking in every viewer's mind is "Who killed Edgar?" As we follow the characters' overlapping narratives and shifting perspectives, we've encountered a host of potential suspects. In Episode 4, we were left with a chilling clue — Sebastian's eerie impersonation of Edgar over the phone. Could this be the key we've been seeking, or is it yet another cunning decoy? Let's grab our magnifying glasses and embark on a deep dive into this riveting enigma.

Before we make any hasty judgements, it's essential to understand the broader context of impersonation in television and film. From Hitchcock's psycho-thrillers to modern-day crime dramas, impersonation often signifies a character's hidden agendas, identity crises, or attempts to manipulate their environment. But could this trope imply Sebastian's guilt, or is it a red herring to lead us off the scent?

The Face Behind The Voice

On the surface, Sebastian's impersonation of Edgar could make him a prime suspect. He could be trying to keep Edgar's "alive" façade to gain control of his business affairs, especially if he were indeed fired by Edgar as Hannah's story suggests. Moreover, it might indicate a sinister motive, including wanting to manipulate Edgar's business or personal relations. We must remember, the stakes are sky-high in this cryptic dance of money, power, and personal vendettas.

Drawing Parallels: Impersonation in TV Land

Television tropes offer tantalizing possibilities. In "Breaking Bad", Walter White's transformation into his alter ego, Heisenberg, symbolizes his descent into the criminal underworld. In "Mad Men", Don Draper's adoption of a dead soldier's identity underlines his yearning for reinvention. Could Sebastian, too, be trying to reinvent himself in Edgar's image, longing to step into the shoes of power and influence that Edgar once wore?

It's A Trap: Beware of The Red Herring

Yet, we must also consider the cunning of "The Afterparty's" creators, who have consistently proven their adeptness at subverting our expectations. Could Sebastian's impersonation be a red herring, a deliberate misdirection to throw us off track? It's not uncommon in crime dramas for suspicious characters to end up being innocents caught in the wrong place at the wrong time, their odd behaviors resulting from unrelated personal demons.

The Power of Misdirection: A Lesson from Agatha Christie

Consider the queen of mystery herself, Agatha Christie, who made a living out of misdirection in her ingenious plots. In "The Murder of Roger Ackroyd," she expertly misled readers through the narrator, only to pull the rug out from under their feet in the stunning climax. Similarly, in "The Afterparty", the creators could be using Sebastian as a narrative decoy, pulling our focus while the real murderer lurks in the shadows.

A Detective's Approach: Consider All Possibilities

From a detective's viewpoint, any piece of evidence, including Sebastian's impersonation, should be scrutinized without jumping to conclusions. While it does add a layer of suspicion to his character, it's crucial to cross-verify this clue with other evidence. After all, he might have been forced into this deceit by some third party, or maybe it was an innocent, though ill-advised, attempt to salvage a business deal in Edgar's absence.

Unmasking The Killer: An Unfinished Puzzle

As we continue our pursuit of Edgar's killer, we need to keep our detective caps on and avoid getting lost in the labyrinth of individual character narratives. While Sebastian's impersonation of Edgar adds a tantalizing twist, it's still just a single piece in a much larger puzzle. To discover the full picture, we'll need to keep watching, analysing, and questioning every move. After all, in the enigmatic world of "The Afterparty", nothing is as straightforward as it seems.

As we eagerly await the next episode, we find ourselves in the grip of a tantalizing mystery that is as much a study of character as it is a whodunit. One thing is certain: with every new piece of the puzzle, "The Afterparty" continues to challenge our assumptions, unravel our theories, and enthrall us with its narrative depth and complexity. So, let's brace ourselves for the rollercoaster ride ahead, where the only certainty is the thrill of the unexpected!

Previous
Previous

Why did Hannah flirt with Travis?

Next
Next

Why did Hannah officiate Grace and Edgar’s wedding?